Anchor Resort and Marina

14424 West Bay Road

Contact: Chris and Linda Drogi
Situated on 6 acres of waterfront property, we offer vacation rentals / cottages, marina, boat slips, boat rentals, gas, pumpouts, on-site playground, basketball court, swim, fish, family-friendly marine services, storage, winterization, and boat hauling.

Black Creek Farm Bed & Breakfast and Barn Venue

13615 Mixer Road, Fair Haven

Bed & Breakfast on 10-acre farm with barn venue.  At Black Creek Farm, we cater to people who want a breath of fresh air and a chance to get away.  You can relax with the charm of the past and the comforts of today.

The Cabin Vacation Rental

14561 Richmond Ave., Fair Haven

Located on Richmond Ave. Cozy cabin nestled in woods. Sleeps eight. Walking distance to village and Fair Haven Beach State Park. Private setting with views of Little Sodus Bay.

The Cottage Farm

14475 Richmond Ave., Fair Haven

Vacation rental propery with pool - 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, single-family house in town with views of Little Sodus Bay.

Fair Haven Motel

8295 Rte. 104A

Motel & Cabins. A great family place to stay. 10 nice rooms plus 8 new cabin rooms. Located just one mile west of the Village of Fair Haven on Route 104A.

Fair Haven White House

14632 Fancher Ave., Fair Haven

Newly renovated home for daily / weekly rental. Three bedroom, 2 bathroom and full kitchen, Bayview with a large yard for campfires & games, and limited water access.

The Got A-Way

8949 Blind Sodus Bay Rd., Red Creek

Rentals situated on over seven beautiful acres. Close to local marina and Little Sodus Bay. Three-unit vacation rental, RV sites, available seasonally, monthly, or daily.

Holiday Harbor Resort

9415 Blind Sodus Bay Road, T/O Wolcott

Contact: Bob Schneider
Beautiful 47 acre RV park with over 1800' of water frontage on Lake Ontario and Blind Sodus Bay. Boat dockage. Boat rental. Cottage rental. Great fishing. Nearby recreation and Golf. 3 miles north of Route 104A. One mile from Fair Haven.

Memory Haven

14496 West Side Drive, Fair Haven

A quiet, peaceful retreat along the Southern shore of Lake Ontario. Located on the Seaway Trail between Rochester and Syracuse in lovely Fair Haven, New York. Ideal for a summer of fall vacation.

Pleasant Beach Hotel

14477 Fancher Ave, Fair Haven

Newly renovated hotel rooms with private bath, overlooking little sodus bay.


Turner's 1816 House B & B

680 Main Street, Fair Haven

Experience the charm of yesteryear, while enjoying the comforts of today in our newly renovated 200 year historic home. All bedrooms have updated private baths, TV, WiFi. Easy walk to beach, downtown shops & restaurants.

Turtle Cove Resort & Marina

356 King Street, Fair Haven

Contact: Brian DiBernardo
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina features a dockside restaurant, 4 cabins with fully equipped kitchens, one cottage & beautiful apartment overlooking the water, boat slips, boat launch, & small store. On Beautiful Little Sodus Bay.