Restaurants & Taverns

Brandon's Pub & Grill

559 Main Street, Fair Haven

Experience the charm of Fair Haven, New York and the historic Little Sodus Bay in an authentic Irish Pub Bar & Grill. We're easy to get to - right in the heart of the Lake Ontario shoreline community. Maybe you'll be heading to the Renaissance Festival this summer? We're less than 10 minutes away. Feel right at home with a cold pint of ale or glass of fine wine, and catch all the sports action on our flat screen TV's.

Colloca Estate Winery

14678 West Bay Road

Waterfront estate includes vineyard, tasting room with gift shop, seasonal outdoor Wine Bar, casual food, live music. Enjoy estate tours and special events throughout the year. Ideal venue for weddings, private parties, and corporate events.

Express Mart at The West End

475 Main Street

Featuring non-ethanol 91 - Gas, AMSOIL, firewood, ice, beer, soda, ATM, Lotto, grocery items. Bait shop - live bait, lures, poles. Camping & RV supplies. Freshly made subs, pizzas, wings - the Best in Town! Fast & Friendly!

Fly By Night Cookie Company

14508 Fancher Avenue

Contact: Bonnie Bridson
Old fashioned pastry shop and miniature museum. Entertainment for the whole family.

Giuseppe's of Fair Haven

591 Main Street, Fair Haven

Keeping the Tradition Alive in Fair Haven! Pizza, wings, subs,
specialty sandwiches, new expanded menu items. Home of Ida’s famous
cheesesteaks! Now offering beer, wine, and hard cider. Eat-in or
carry-out. Live entertainment and more.

Hardware Cafe

566 Main Street, Fair Haven

Experience great local flavor in an unique, historic building in downtown Fair Haven. Full breakfast and lunch daily, gourmet coffees, home-made soups, desserts and weekend dinner specials. Featuring local products, quality apparel, gifts, antiques and uniques.

Little Sodus Inn on the Bay

14451 Bell Avenue, Fair Haven

Quaint waterfront bar with light food & picnic tables. Dock rentals. Accommodations include two fully furnished cottages & one large summer home.

Pleasant Beach Hotel

14477 Fancher Ave, Fair Haven

Established 1910. This historic building is unique in many ways offering beautiful hotel rooms, bar, restaurant & marina overlooking Little Sodus Bay.


Sterling Cidery

14451 Richmond Ave., Fair Haven

We're a new cidery, offering our own craft ciders on draft in our
tasting room in Fair Haven Village.

The Village Grill of Fair Haven

(315) 947-5200
809 St. Rte 104A, Sterling

Family style restaurant just on the edge of town serving breakfast and lunch Wednesday through Sunday, and dinner Thursday through Saturday. Featuring fresh homemade meals "where family and friends gather".

Turtle Cove Resort & Marina

(315) 947-6677
356 King Street, Fair Haven

Contact: Brian DiBernardo
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina features a dockside restaurant, 4 cabins with fully equipped kitchens, one cottage & beautiful apartment overlooking the water, boat slips, boat launch, & small store. On Beautiful Little Sodus Bay.